20 November 2021
Dinner party with Marguerite Matisse
"Let's face it, The French hate painting!" There! I've said it. My point, though not always immediately understood, nor possibly even true, was always about how cerebral the French are as a cultural whole and that Painting was way too emotional for them to appreciate. Now, I've really put my foot into the apple tarte.
But, I plunged my sword further into the startled dinner party, I exclaimed, “But the British! Now, they are people who truly love Painting, because despite their squeamish attention to manners and social protocol (in reverse to the French) they are truly eccentric, and they possess a non-conformist streak (also in reverse to the French who are stridently conformist, if you permit my penchant for lobbing labels around). I pontificated even further and said that the Brits are sufficiently odd enough to appreciate the softened sensuality of the messy nature of Painting. The British love Painting as do the Dutch and the Danes, like the Belgians do, and the Italians too. But at the same time all of them are equally mad about Conceptual Art because they can all chew gum and drink beer at the same time.
But the French, on the other hand, are mad for Literature and Poetry, and they adore contemporary Architecture and cool Opera. But more than anything, they worship wordplay. Conversation skills are a must in France, especially so in Paris. Their passion is really for ideas and razor sharp brilliance. So naturally, they are more comfortable with Conceptual Art than with mere paintings that can rip through ideas like a table saw. They love Robert Wilson, not Robert Johnson. But I won’t try to convince anyone here of all this, not now, anyway.
These bombs were always fun to throw into these intimate dinner parties. My success rate was often contingent upon how much, or little wine, I had consumed during the meal. And to be fair, these were my friends for the most part so they were quite used to my antics. Being an American at certain times gave me a wide birth in most situations.
Despite the light-hearted deliveries at these dinners, the core of these bombs were quite real for me, personally. I still believe even today, so many years later, that the Painting medium can rarely tolerate, with much conviction, or success, an overload of too many concepts and ideas. Unlike Americans, the French, even though they are eloquent speakers, are just never comfortable expressing feelings about themselves (except in French cinema, theatre, and books of course) Their passion hides behind their reserve. ‘La pudeur’ is a fine and sophisticated quality which the French possess in boatloads (ditto for the Japanese) unlike us Americans, who barge into rooms uninvited, then when leaving them, we leave the lights on. The French have passion for ideas, and ideals, and for that, we love and cherish them all the more so.
One of my favourite Matisse portraits is this one he painted of his daughter Marguerite. This one is in Paris at the Musée Picasso although I could swear that I've seen it at the Musée de Grenoble too. It is dated between 1906-7, and it is so simply done that it takes my breath away. Like the drawing, its colour harmony is simple, austere even, but for me, it houses just enough feeling to keep me transfixed. It's created with an almost primitive form of expression as if it were painted on a farm somewhere in rural France by an amateur. This is perhaps why I like it so much; there is a complete lack of any pretension, technical, or otherwise in it. For me, when he was at his best, it was always without pretence.
This loving father always painted his daughter with a ribbon or scarf around her neck to hide the scar from a tracheotomy she had endured early in childhood. Later on, Marguerite was in the Resistance during the war and was captured and tortured by the Gestapo. She was very lucky to have lived through it. And testament to her father’s adoration, we have many, many portraits of her today. As a painter, it speaks to how uncomplicated Painting can be when everything works in a simple way. I think that a primal image like this is born at an early stage in a painter's life. It grows patiently within, almost unbeknownst to the painter himself. It has always been there, inchoate, and waiting for an occasion to appear. One cannot set out to make a picture like this. An image such as this seems to blossom naturally like an awkward young girl of 13, who, on the cusp of womanhood, becomes suddenly aware of her new form.
Of all his portraits of Marguerite, this is my preferred, and I love it like an old Zen Master cherishes his favourite tea cup.